Cahiers: There is no clash between ancient and modern?
Godard: None at all. There may be technical progress, but no revolution in style, or at least not yet.
After a while enough quantitative change (technical progress) becomes a qualitative change (style), and that happened sometime in the early 1970’s with Peckinpah and Altman. Everything is in colour, the camera moves more fluidly, the sound is better caught, the acting is less obvious, looser and less stylised (compare Olivier with Branagh in Henry V, and try not to wince at Olivier). But those changes of style do not (always) make a clash.
Let’s play Make A Double-Bill. One film from before 1960, and one from after 1980.
Sam Fuller’s Park Row
followed by John Hughes’ The Breakfast Club
The difference in style could hardly be greater: especially between the stylised 1950’s acting against the naturalism of the Brat Pack, colour vs black-and-white, and the difference in the issues of the movies: freedom of the Press for Fuller and, well, what exactly for Hughes? Fuller’s is an action-packed movie about grown-ups doing grown-up things, whereas Hughes’ movie is about a bunch of teenagers doing inconsequential teenage stuff. Park Row should make The Breakfast Club look like fluff. Both films are about a bunch of rag-tag renegades, lead by a charismatic Bad Boy, taking on the establishment, where the real character interest is in the supporting cast. And that’s enough, at least for me.
Steve Kloves’ Fabulous Baker Boys followed by Vincente Minnelli’s American In Paris. Both are films about artists barely getting by, with no obvious futures. Both have love affairs, though Gene Kelly gets the girl and Jeff Bridges does not. Both have tour-de-force performances - the ballet in Minelli’s film, and the Making Whopee number in Kloves’. These similarities will carry us over the difference between 1950’s and 1990’s colour film, and the conventions of the musical vs the conventions of the cynical downbeat movie.
Richard Curtis’ Four Weddings and a Funeral followed by Michael Curtis’ Casablanca. Hugh Grant is the anti-Bogart. Casablanca is about cynical people doing good things despite themselves, Four Weddings and a Funeral is about naive twits stumbling into whatever good or bad comes their way. Both are fairy-tales because in reality neither of those things happen. Both have an implausible relationship (Hugh Grant and Andi McDowell, Humphrey Bogart and Claude Rains) running through the movie and only resolved at the end. Both have a strong sense of place, literally in Casablanca, and figuratively in Four Weddings’ portrayal of the world of the English upper-class.
You could watch those double-bills without thinking you had put sugar on your fries.
There are a number of genres I think don’t sit alongside pre-1960’s movies. CGI-heavy superhero movies. Superhero comics and movies are not, with the exceptions of some of Alan Moore and Warren Ellis, about character. They are about special effects and heroes that can do impossible things, such as disguising themselves as Clark Kent or Peter Parker. Chop-socky Hong Kong? There’s no pairing John Woo’s Face/Off with anything before 1960. Then, all those grim 2000 / 2010’s movies from the former Communist Bloc countries: Cristian Mungiu’s Four Months, Three Weeks and Two Days, or Andrey Zvyagintsev’s Leviathon for instance. Add those charming films from Korea and Japan: nothing made before 1960 is as cute as Jeong Jae-eun’s Take Care of my Cat. Or how about Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s 5-hour marathon Happy Hour? (Worth every minute). The French life-of-the-bourgeios-movie, from Rohmer to the full 4 hours of Jacques Rivette’s La Belle Noiseuse? . There’s a bunch of films which treat their slightly quirky characters kindly, in which nothing dramatic happens, and yet we sit fascinated (think Rohmer again, and Wim Wender’s Perfect Days), and perhaps soothed by the fairy-tale simplicity of their lives. That is not to be found anywhere before about 1980.
It’s not style that makes two films jar. It’s a clash of the vision of the director and writer, the underlying values, and the purpose of the story. Try matching anything with the mutiply-directed The Wizard of Oz. You rightly suspect something dodgy is going on, even if you can’t put your finger on it. You would be right: it is really agit-prop, for the Gold Standard (doesn’t that change the way you understand `follow the yellow-brick road’). So maybe it could be matched with Leni Riefenstahl’s Triumph of The Will, but only if that came second. They don’t make double-bills like that anymore.
After a while enough quantitative change (technical progress) becomes a qualitative change (style), and that happened sometime in the early 1970’s with Peckinpah and Altman. Everything is in colour, the camera moves more fluidly, the sound is better caught, the acting is less obvious, looser and less stylised (compare Olivier with Branagh in Henry V, and try not to wince at Olivier). But those changes of style do not (always) make a clash.
Let’s play Make A Double-Bill. One film from before 1960, and one from after 1980.
Sam Fuller’s Park Row
followed by John Hughes’ The Breakfast Club
The difference in style could hardly be greater: especially between the stylised 1950’s acting against the naturalism of the Brat Pack, colour vs black-and-white, and the difference in the issues of the movies: freedom of the Press for Fuller and, well, what exactly for Hughes? Fuller’s is an action-packed movie about grown-ups doing grown-up things, whereas Hughes’ movie is about a bunch of teenagers doing inconsequential teenage stuff. Park Row should make The Breakfast Club look like fluff. Both films are about a bunch of rag-tag renegades, lead by a charismatic Bad Boy, taking on the establishment, where the real character interest is in the supporting cast. And that’s enough, at least for me.
Steve Kloves’ Fabulous Baker Boys followed by Vincente Minnelli’s American In Paris. Both are films about artists barely getting by, with no obvious futures. Both have love affairs, though Gene Kelly gets the girl and Jeff Bridges does not. Both have tour-de-force performances - the ballet in Minelli’s film, and the Making Whopee number in Kloves’. These similarities will carry us over the difference between 1950’s and 1990’s colour film, and the conventions of the musical vs the conventions of the cynical downbeat movie.
Richard Curtis’ Four Weddings and a Funeral followed by Michael Curtis’ Casablanca. Hugh Grant is the anti-Bogart. Casablanca is about cynical people doing good things despite themselves, Four Weddings and a Funeral is about naive twits stumbling into whatever good or bad comes their way. Both are fairy-tales because in reality neither of those things happen. Both have an implausible relationship (Hugh Grant and Andi McDowell, Humphrey Bogart and Claude Rains) running through the movie and only resolved at the end. Both have a strong sense of place, literally in Casablanca, and figuratively in Four Weddings’ portrayal of the world of the English upper-class.
You could watch those double-bills without thinking you had put sugar on your fries.
There are a number of genres I think don’t sit alongside pre-1960’s movies. CGI-heavy superhero movies. Superhero comics and movies are not, with the exceptions of some of Alan Moore and Warren Ellis, about character. They are about special effects and heroes that can do impossible things, such as disguising themselves as Clark Kent or Peter Parker. Chop-socky Hong Kong? There’s no pairing John Woo’s Face/Off with anything before 1960. Then, all those grim 2000 / 2010’s movies from the former Communist Bloc countries: Cristian Mungiu’s Four Months, Three Weeks and Two Days, or Andrey Zvyagintsev’s Leviathon for instance. Add those charming films from Korea and Japan: nothing made before 1960 is as cute as Jeong Jae-eun’s Take Care of my Cat. Or how about Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s 5-hour marathon Happy Hour? (Worth every minute). The French life-of-the-bourgeios-movie, from Rohmer to the full 4 hours of Jacques Rivette’s La Belle Noiseuse? . There’s a bunch of films which treat their slightly quirky characters kindly, in which nothing dramatic happens, and yet we sit fascinated (think Rohmer again, and Wim Wender’s Perfect Days), and perhaps soothed by the fairy-tale simplicity of their lives. That is not to be found anywhere before about 1980.
It’s not style that makes two films jar. It’s a clash of the vision of the director and writer, the underlying values, and the purpose of the story. Try matching anything with the mutiply-directed The Wizard of Oz. You rightly suspect something dodgy is going on, even if you can’t put your finger on it. You would be right: it is really agit-prop, for the Gold Standard (doesn’t that change the way you understand `follow the yellow-brick road’). So maybe it could be matched with Leni Riefenstahl’s Triumph of The Will, but only if that came second. They don’t make double-bills like that anymore.
